Best Catholic primary schools in South Yorkshire (2026)
South Yorkshire has 32 ranked Catholic primary schools with published results. The top-ranked is St Wilfrid's Catholic Primary School, in the top 11% in England. The average reading, writing & maths here in 2025 was 57%, against 62% for England. 0 are in England's top 10%, and 2 are rated Outstanding by Ofsted.
| Rank | School | Reading, writing & maths (2023–2025 average) | Reading, writing & maths 2025 | Trend | Higher standard | Ofsted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 Top 11% in England |
St Wilfrid's Catholic Primary School Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
80% | 77% | 5% | Good (2022) | |
2 Top 17% in England |
St John Fisher Primary, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
78% | 81% | 9% | Standards maintained (2024) | |
3 Top 22% in England |
St Gerard's Catholic Primary School Thrybergh and Dalton · Roman Catholic |
70% | 79% | 26% | Good or better in every area (2025) | |
4 Top 25% in England |
St Mary's Primary School, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Chapeltown and High Green · Roman Catholic |
72% | 79% | 8% | Report card 2026: Expected standard or better in every area | |
5 Top 29% in England |
St Bede's Catholic Primary School Rotherham · Catholic |
69% | 69% | 10% | Good or better in every area (2024) | |
6 Top 31% in England |
St Marie's School, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
72% | 76% | 0% | Remains Good (2022) | |
7 Top 33% in England |
St Joseph's School, a Catholic Voluntary Academy New Rossington and Rossington · Roman Catholic |
65% | 69% | 17% | Standards maintained (2025) | |
8 Top 33% in England |
Our Lady and St Joseph's Catholic Primary School Wath upon Dearne · Roman Catholic |
69% | 69% | 14% | Remains Good (2024) | |
9 Top 34% in England |
St Mary's Catholic Primary School Rotherham · Roman Catholic |
72% | 74% | 0% | Good (2023) | |
10 Top 40% in England |
St Catherine's Catholic Primary School Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
68% | 75% | 4% | Remains Outstanding (2022) | |
11 Top 40% in England |
St Thomas More Catholic Primary, A Voluntary Academy Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
68% | 57% | 0% | Remains Good (2024) | |
12 Top 42% in England |
Sacred Heart School, A Catholic Voluntary Academy Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
63% | 69% | 3% | Report card 2026: Expected standard or better in every area | |
13 Top 45% in England |
Holy Family Catholic Primary School Stainforth · Roman Catholic |
62% | 52% | 14% | Outstanding (2024) | |
14 Bottom 47% in England |
St Thomas of Canterbury School, a Catholic Voluntary Academy Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
63% | 67% | 4% | Good or better in every area (2025) | |
15 Bottom 45% in England |
Our Lady of Sorrows Catholic Voluntary Academy Armthorpe · Roman Catholic |
63% | 71% | 0% | Standards maintained (2025) | |
16 Bottom 45% in England |
St Peter's Catholic Primary School Doncaster · Roman Catholic |
61% | 59% | 0% | Standards maintained (2025) | |
17 Bottom 42% in England |
St Alban's Catholic Primary and Nursery School Denaby Main · Roman Catholic |
62% | 58% | 0% | Good or better in every area (2025) | |
18 Bottom 36% in England |
Holy Rood Catholic Primary School Barnsley · Roman Catholic |
57% | 53% | 3% | Standards maintained (2024) | |
19 Bottom 32% in England |
St Mary's Catholic Primary School, Edlington Warmsworth · Roman Catholic |
57% | 71% | 4% | Report card 2026: Expected standard or better in every area | |
20 Bottom 30% in England |
St Joseph's Catholic Primary School Rawmarsh · Roman Catholic |
55% | 48% | 4% | Good (2024) | |
21 Bottom 30% in England |
Our Lady of Perpetual Help Catholic Primary School Bentley (Doncaster) · Roman Catholic |
55% | 60% | 0% | Report card 2026: Expected standard or better in every area | |
22 Bottom 28% in England |
Our Lady of Mount Carmel Catholic Primary School Doncaster · Roman Catholic |
55% | 47% | 7% | Standards maintained (2025) | |
23 Bottom 27% in England |
St Theresa's Catholic Primary School Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
55% | 42% | 0% | Remains Good (2023) | |
24 Bottom 24% in England |
St Francis Xavier Catholic Primary School Doncaster · Roman Catholic |
51% | 69% | 10% | Remains Good (2024) | |
25 Bottom 23% in England |
St Michael and All Angels Catholic Primary School Wombwell · Roman Catholic |
53% | 50% | 0% | Remains Good (2024) | |
26 Bottom 13% in England |
St Ann's Catholic Primary School, A Voluntary Academy Stocksbridge · Roman Catholic |
45% | 50% | 0% | Standards maintained (2025) | |
27 Bottom 11% in England |
St Joseph's Primary School Sheffield · Roman Catholic |
46% | 30% | 0% | Good (2024) | |
28 Bottom 10% in England |
St Joseph and St Teresa's Catholic Primary School Adwick le Street · Roman Catholic |
44% | 55% | 5% | Good (2023) | |
29 Bottom 9% in England |
Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School Goldthorpe · Roman Catholic |
44% | 35% | 0% | Some aspects not as strong (2025) | |
30 Bottom 5% in England |
St Helen's Catholic Primary School Hoyland · Roman Catholic |
38% | 0% | 0% | Remains Good (2023) | |
31 Bottom 4% in England |
St Joseph's Catholic Primary School Dinnington (Rotherham) · Roman Catholic |
36% | 11% | 0% | Standards maintained (2024) | |
32 Bottom 1% in England |
St Mary's Catholic Primary School (Maltby) Maltby · Roman Catholic |
27% | 29% | 4% | Good (2022) |
Questions
What is the best Catholic primary school in South Yorkshire?
On exam results over the last three years, St Wilfrid's Catholic Primary School is the top-ranked Catholic primary school in South Yorkshire, in the top 11% of schools in England.
How are the schools ranked?
By published Department for Education exam results averaged over three years: for secondary schools, Attainment 8 plus a quarter of the share getting grade 5+ in English and maths; for primary schools, the share reaching the expected standard in reading, writing and maths plus half the share reaching the higher standard. Small schools are pulled towards the average by how much their results could be down to chance, so a school with a small year group does not top or bottom the table by luck. The order uses the three-year average, so a school can rank above one with a higher single-year result. Schools with fewer than 10 pupils taking the tests are not ranked. Exam results are only part of the picture: visit, read the Ofsted report and check admissions rules, as living nearby does not guarantee a place.